Outpatient Treatment & Recovery Management: Longterm Support and Monitoring of SUD Recovery

candle-in-hand-twin-town

Addiction, otherwise known as “Substance Use Disorder” (SUD) is a relapsing, chronic disease which requires lifelong cognitive, behavioral, social and physiological change and maintenance. Outpatient treatment and “recovery management” are designed to prevent addiction related deterioration, morbidity, relapse, and death. Outpatient treatment and recovery management also provide solutions which guide addicted people toward resources designed to better meet their needs and away from inappropriate, costly, and restrictive levels of supervision such as residential institutions, hospitals, and jails.

Since the 1930’s it has been demonstrated that successful, lifelong recovery from the disease of addiction can be achieved by engaging in recovery promoting activity, social support and benevolent service. Attempts at providing professionally provided acute care medical and time-limited psycho-social interventions to this chronic disease as resulted in partial solutions and modest outcomes.

What appears to be missing in the current model of addiction treatment is long-term recovery follow-up and monitoring. Investments in thirty-day to nine-month courses of treatment in inpatient, residential or sober living settings are being lost when the patient returns home and/or over the course of time.

Cognitive and behavioral gains fail to generalize into normal life settings after discharge from a residential setting. Relapse often follows. In the absence of practicing recovery in real time, in real life, over time, recovery deteriorates. Recovery management aids to assess and supervise recover in the long-term.

The commercialization of addiction treatment and recovery has resulted in expensive services which result in occasionally good short-term outcomes. The motive for providing these services is too often fee-for-service profiteering. When the payor and payment for services is exhausted, there are no resource left for integrating clinical gains into real-life circumstances. Recovery management has been abandoned to “self-sustained” sobriety, sometimes with peer support.

“Shift by government and private sources from purchasing time, or session-limited units of service – to purchasing and integrated program of management and support for long-term recovery; shift in emphasis from treatment intensity (crisis stabilization) to treatment extensity (prolonged recovery maintenance).”(1)

Mutual support groups offer peer support on a voluntary basis. This has been an effective model for people who remain willing and open to recovery despite its challenges and demands for change. People who encounter periods of ambivalence, avoidance, defiance or other roadblocks benefit from professionally provided recovery management which is designed to anticipate and prevent incidents of recovery deterioration and relapse. Recovery management also offers professional contact, support and access to assistance regardless of the person’s level of willingness.

Outpatient treatment and recovery management differ from the “acute care model” in that a multitude of highly restrictive and costly resources is not required in the entry level of care, save medical detox in selective cases. Outpatient treatment and recovery management provides case management, coaching and support over the long-term, in the natural environment where the client resides.

The distractions, triggers and the wreckage from reckless drug/ alcohol influenced behavior must be encountered early in sobriety so that specific recovery skills are exercised in the context where they are needed. If a person new to recovery encounters these stimuli for the first time without the support and guidance of professionals and peers, relapse is likely.

Outpatient treatment and recovery management must be provided in “real time” during “real life”, to pursue “real life opportunities” and to cope with “real life events”.

“Treatment on an outpatient basis allows a more valid assessment of environmental, cognitive and emotional antecedents of drinking episodes and drinking urges on the part of the patient, and allows the patient to test new coping strategies while still within a supportive counseling relationship.

These conditions would be expected to foster greater generalization of learning in treatment to the patient’s natural environment” (2)

Learned ideas and behaviors are not applied in real life unless new skills are practiced and coached. (3) Studies reveal that didactic teaching provides participants no practical benefit. Didactic teaching which includes role-playing or in-class practice results in no lasting practical benefit. Only when teaching and practice are applied to real life situations followed by coaching and follow-up are behavioral improvements achieved. (4) (5)

Outpatient treatment of substance use disorders and recovery management allows for the practice and exercise of pro-recovery skills in the real world. Coaching and follow-up after real-world exercise allow for supportive, reinforcing and corrective steps toward strengthened recovery and guiding away from relapse towards greater resilience.

Patients develop the skills and self-confidence to cope with high-risk situations such as negative emotional states, interpersonal conflict, and social pressure to drink. The informal use of similar coping strategies may contribute to the success of 12-step self-help programs. (5)

References:

(1) White, W.L. & McLeallan, A.T. (2008) Addiction as a chronic disease: Key messages for clients, families and referral sources. Counselor, 9(3), 24-33.
(2) Annis, 1986, p. 183
(3) “Meta-analysis of Effects of Training and Coaching on Teacher’s Implementation in Classroom”, Joyce & Showers, 2002
(4) “Impact of Formal Continuing Medical Education- Do Conferences, Workshops, Rounds and Other Traditional Continuing Education Activities Change Physician behavior or Health Care Outcomes”, Dave Davis, MD, The Journal of the American Medical Association
(5) Kelly et. al. 2000
(6) “Evaluating Substance Abuse Treatment Process Models: I. Changes on Proximal Outcome Variables during 12-step and Cognitive Behavioral Treatment”, Finney, Moyes, Coutts, Moos, Journal of Studies on Alcohol, ‘98

Building Recovery Skills at Home, Work and School

SproutWithout the transfer of recovery skills and support into the home, work and school environments, wreckage, triggers and interpersonal conflicts create a high probability of relapse and the loss of the recovery investment.

Outpatient treatment integrates recovery at home in the normal environment. Outpatient treatment provides a path to recovery which is:

  • 100% Take-Home;
  • Organic, Locally Grown;
  • Sustainable;
  • Integrated;
  • Developed from Practical, Relevant Skills;
  • Established by Authentic Relationships;
  • Accesses Local, Authentic Sober Supports.

“Treatment on an outpatient basis allows a more valid assessment of environmental, cognitive and emotional antecedents of drinking episodes and drinking urges on the part of the patient, and allows the patient to test new coping strategies while still within a supportive counseling relationship.

These conditions would be expected to foster greater generalization of learning in treatment to the patient’s natural environment” (Annis, 1986, p. 183).

“Previous reviews have concluded that there was no evidence for the superiority of inpatient over outpatient treatment of alcohol abuse, although particular types of patients might be more effectively treated in inpatient settings.” The effectiveness of inpatient and outpatient treatment for alcohol abuse: the need to focus on mediators and moderators of setting effects, JOHN W. FINNEY, ANNETTE C. HAHN, RUDOLF H. MOOS Article first published online: 24 JAN 2006 DOI: 10.1046/j.1360-0443.1996.911217733.x Addiction Volume 91, Issue 12, pages 1773–1796, December 1996

“…(M)ore severe patients experienced better alcohol and drug outcomes following in-patient/residential treatment versus out-patient treatment; on the other hand, patients with lower baseline ASI drug severity had better drug outcomes following out-patient treatment than in-patient treatment. Treatment setting was unrelated to alcohol outcomes in patients with less severe ASI alcohol scores.” Day Hospital and Residential Addiction Treatment: Randomized and Nonrandomized Managed Care Clients; Jane Witbrodt, Jason Bond, and Lee Ann Kaskutas Alcohol Research Group, Constance Weisner, University of California, San Francisco, Gary Jaeger; Kaiser Foundation Hospital, David Pating, Kaiser San Francisco Medical Center, Charles Moore Sacramento Kaiser Permanente, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology Copyright 2007 by the American Psychological Association, 2007, Vol. 75, No. 6, 947–95

Recovery Shouldn’t be Expensive! … Affordable Substance Abuse (Addiction) Treatment

You can pay $60,000 ($60K) per month in Malibu or West Palm Beach, $37K “Out-of-Network” from your insurance, $14K “In-Network” with your insurance coverage, or you can simply pay whatever your deductible and co-payment is for an average of twenty-five substance abuse/ addiction sessions at Twin Town Treatment Centers. Once an average of twenty-five billed sessions is complete, Twin Town provides four additional months of aftercare.

If you paid out of pocket, a five (5) month episode of substance abuse/ addiction treatment at Twin Town Treatment Centers would run approximately $4.5 K.

Optum Health, a nationally recognized behavioral health managed care organization published a white paper, which states the following:

“Sensing both demand for services and higher rolls of young adults on their parents’ insurance, entrepreneurs have opened new centers for treatment of substance use disorders. Many of these are in “destination” locales, in states far from patients’ homes. In our estimation, however, those are often not the most appropriate or effective settings for treatment for these reasons:

  1. When individuals can be treated for a substance use disorder in or near their home communities, they often stand a better chance of long-term recovery. Their families and close friends can be part of their recovery, and the individuals in treatment learn how to be sober in the surroundings where they will continue their lives.
  1. Close analysis of claims from some treatment centers bears witness to questionable practices in treatment protocols and in billing patients, families and their insurance companies. A particular area of abuse is in the use of and billing for drug screenings through laboratory tests that are being administered inappropriately, far more frequently than required, at rates well beyond the usual and customary charges.

CLAIMS COSTS FOR SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER TREATMENT IN FLORIDA

The costs of treatment in out-of-network facilities were, on average, three times higher than the costs of treating at in-network facilities.

Nearly 75 percent of the cases of young adults treated in Florida involved individuals who were not residents of that state.

Individuals from outside the state treated at out-of-network facilities were readmitted at higher rates — between 11 percent and 40 percent higher, depending on level of care — than Florida residents who used in-network facilities.

CLAIMS COSTS FOR SUBSTANCE USE DISORDER TREATMENT IN FLORIDA 18- TO 25-YEAR-OLD DEPENDENTS:

Out-of-Network (63% of members) per member $36,645

In-Network (27% of members) per member $13,692.”

Drug and Alcohol Abuse, The Addiction Crisis – SAMHSA

Substance use/misuse and addiction represent a significant and substantial public health challenge. Data from the 2014 National Survey on Drug Use and Health (NSDUH) reveal that an estimated 27.0 million Americans aged 12 or older were currently illicit drug users (defined as using any of the following in the past 30 days: Marijuana/hashish, cocaine/crack, heroin, hallucinogens, inhalants, or non-medical use of prescription-type psychotherapeutics such as pain relievers, tranquilizers, stimulants, and sedatives) and 16.3 million were heavy drinkers (defined as drinking five or more drinks on the same occasion on five or more days in the past 30 days). Approximately 6.5 million people aged 12 and older reported currently using psychotherapeutics non-medically.

According to the 2014 NSDUH, 21.5 million Americans aged 12 or older had a substance use disorder in the past year. Among them, 14.4 million Americans had dependence or abuse of alcohol but not illicit drugs, while another 4.5 million had dependence or abuse of illicit drugs but not alcohol, and 2.6 million had dependence or abuse of both alcohol and illicit drugs. People with alcohol or illicit drug dependence or abuse were defined in the 2014 NSDUH as meeting the diagnostic criteria specified in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth edition (DSM-IV).

The Affordable Care Act and new mental health parity protections are expanding mental health and substance abuse treatment benefits to 60 million Americans. Despite this historic expansion of health insurance coverage and other advances, too many Americans are not benefiting from treatment services. Based on the 2014 NSDUH data, although 21.5 million people aged 12 or older met the DSM-IV criteria for alcohol or illicit drug dependence or abuse, only an estimated 2.3 million received substance use treatment in the past year.

Drug poisoning (overdose) was responsible for about 47,000 deaths in the U.S. in 2014 (now the latest year for which national data are available). Furthermore, substance misuse (to include excessive alcohol use) and related disorders contribute to injury and chronic illness, lost productivity, family disruptions, and increased transmission of sexually and injection-related infectious diseases; are associated with higher rates of domestic violence and child abuse; and prevent many individuals from realizing their full potential.

Family Response to Drug Abuse and the Holidays

If a loved one shows up, ruining family events and holidays under the influence of alcohol or drugs, what should I do?

  1. Distinguish the love you have for the person from the frustration you feel about their behavior. Talk openly about the two with your loved one and your family.
  2. Talk openly with your family and the person with the substance use problem about the problem. Don’t keep secrets.
  3. “Invite them to get help”- pushing/ controlling usually makes things worse. Take care of yourself and your family by setting limits.
  4. Set limits with your loved one and let them know that you will drive them to a treatment center to get help.
  5. Set limits with your loved one and let them know that you will drive them back home if they show up or become drunken or drugged.
  6. Set limits with your loved one and tell them that family time is off-limits for drunken or drugged behavior.
  7. Make it clear to your loved one and your family that they are “sick”, not “bad”.
  8. Communicate “stern love”: you care so much that you want to help them get well, rather than supporting them to destroy themselves.

How can I prepare my family for another holiday with someone’s alcohol or drug abuse problem?

  1. Before holidays and family events, communicate openly with the family and the loved one with the alcohol or drug problem and set a plan.
  2. Decide upon responses to and limit setting about drunk or drugged behavior and follow-though!
  3. Let the person with the alcohol or drug use problem know that the family loves them and only wants to help them get better.
  4. Communicate to the family and loved one the meaning of “enabling”: supporting continued alcohol or drug abuse by avoiding, ignoring, or enabling drunk or drugged behavior.
  5. Offer to meet with the substance abusing loved one before the event or holiday to discuss how their problem affects you, and to help find them treatment for the problem.
  6. Call a professional or treatment program before you meet with the loved one so as to prepare for an opportunity to help them get better.

What do I do if my loved one with the alcohol or drug use problem denies their problem or gets angry?

  1. Communicate “stern love”: you care so much that you want to help them get well, rather than continue to destroy themselves.
  2. Use the “broken record” technique”: repeat what you are saying if it isn’t being heard or considered.
  3. Express your caring, compassionate feelings before expressing your frustration.
  4. Recall and discuss incidents where drunk or drugged behavior ruined family events or holidays. Describe your past excuses for their behavior.
  5. Attempt to get the help of a professional or a friend who has experience with recovery.
  6. Step away from the conversation if you find yourself becoming angry or controlling.

What do I do if a family member or members don’t want to deal with or talk about the problem?

  1. Let them know that secrets and silence enables alcohol and drug abuse to grow into deeper, more dangerous conditions.
  2. Remind them of past occasions where family events or holidays were ruined by drunk or drugged behavior.
  3. Discuss possible consequences of your loved one’s continued alcohol or drug abuse.
  4. Discuss possible outcomes of talking openly with your loved one about their problem.
  5. Suggest reading material related to alcohol and drug abuse/ addiction.
  6. Set a plan.

Dark Web Marketplace Increases Availability, Acceptability of Drugs: Expert

dark-web-featuredThe popularity of the “Dark Web” for purchasing illegal drugs is especially worrisome because it is increasing the availability and acceptability of drugs, according to an addiction psychiatry expert.

“After talking with people who use the Dark Web, I became very concerned that many of them have lost the appreciation that this is drug dealing, not just e-commerce,” says Karen Miotto, MD, Director of UCLA’s Addiction Psychiatry Service, who has studied the Dark Web, also known as the Deep Web or the Hidden Web. “Buying or selling heroin balloons in the park is clearly understood as an illegal activity; buying or selling drugs online may be construed as e-commerce without full appreciation that it is also illegal.”

The Dark Web refers to illegal online marketplaces that can be accessed by downloading the anonymous browser called Tor, and purchasing the digital currently bitcoin. In addition to illegal drugs, these websites sell passports, pornography and weapons.

The first and most well-known Dark Web site was Silk Road, which was shut down by the federal government in 2013.

The ease with which people can buy large quantities of drugs is creating a system with mid-level drug dealers, said Dr. Miotto, who discussed the Dark Web at the recent California Society of Addiction Medicine annual meeting.

She found people who use the Dark Web by asking students and colleagues for contacts, as well as through the website Reddit.

“We have a new drug distribution system,” Dr. Miotto said. “People can get drugs sent to them in a FedEx box right to their door with a sense of anonymity and confidentiality. There’s a sense of intrigue and excitement about getting drugs this way.”

Earlier this year, a study by Carnegie Mellon University researchers found illegal websites have sales that average $300,000 to $500,000 a day. The study found marijuana accounted for about one-quarter of sales, followed by Ecstasy and stimulants. These websites also sell significant amounts of psychedelic drugs, opioids and other prescription medications.

Dr. Miotto found that hallucinogenic compounds advertised as research chemicals are popular on Dark Web sites. “Some people believe they are performing a service by experimenting with these drugs and going online and writing about their experience,” she said.

When Silk Road was seized in October 2013, it had 13,000 drug listings. In June, the creator of Silk Road, Ross Ulbricht, was sentenced to life in prison. The government said over Silk Road’s three years in business, more than 1.5 million transactions were conducted on the site.

A number of new Dark Web sites have emerged since Silk Road was seized, including Open Bazaar, Silk Road 3.0 and Angora. “People write in testimonials about the drugs they purchase on these sites, just as you do on Amazon,” Dr. Miotto notes.

She said parents’ and physicians’ ignorance of the Dark Web makes it easier for young people to participate in the online drug marketplace. “Young people don’t always appreciate the risk they are taking in engaging in these activities,” she said. Parents can check to see if a Tor browser has been downloaded on their teen’s computer. Check packages that come to the house, and don’t allow your teen to have their own Post Office box. If your teen asks about Bitcoin, find out what he knows about it and why he’s interested in it.

“I worry about young people with disposable income and access to credit cards,” Dr. Miotto said. “Some of the most tragic cases I’ve seen are high school kids, or even younger, with a lot of discretionary income.”

http://www.drugfree.org/join-together/dark-web-marketplace-increases-availability-acceptability-drugs-expert/?utm_source=Stay+Informed+-+latest+tips%2C+resources+and+news&utm_campaign=557a1db87b-JTWN_PrntsChldrnDdHrnOdClfrChngsnAppch11515&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_34168a2307-557a1db87b-223279565

What does the research say about Intensive Outpatient and Day

Treatment working as well or better than residential treatment for alcohol and drug abuse and addiction:

“Treatment on an outpatient basis allows a more valid assessment of environmental, cognitive and emotional antecedents of drinking episodes and drinking urges on the part of the patient, and allows the patient to test new coping strategies while still within a supportive counseling relationship. These conditions would be expected to foster greater generalization of learning in treatment to the patient’s natural environment” (Annis, 1986, p. 183).

 

What are some of the different features of outpatient treatment which create better outcomes than in residential treatment setting?

  • Therapeutic and supportive relationships are not disrupted in outpatient treatment.
  • Therapeutic rapport with therapists, psychiatrists, prior sobriety supports and physicians are maintained.
  • Strengths and assets at work, home, recreation can be built upon during the course of outpatient treatment.

 

Isn’t learning new skills and avoiding drug and alcohol use at home more difficult than in a clean and supervised environment?

  • Rather than learning in a nice clean laboratory, apply the new skills directly into your life now. Outpatient treatment provides a much greater “take-home” advantage.

 

The benefits of getting sober at home actually enable newly sober people to

  • Practice new skills immediately in real-life situations;
  • Apply new discoveries, ideas and behavioral changes- practice improves retention;
  • As clients and families learn more effective coping, communication and relationship skills, they can “practice” these skills both in treatment and at home
  • Clients and families receive support and validation from each other while expanding their lasting sober supports in outpatient settings. Relationships can be maintained and won’t be disrupted at discharge as in residential treatment.

 

While you participate in an intensive outpatient or day treatment program for alcohol and drug abuse and addiction, what sober resources are found at home different from those in a residential program?

  • Outpatient treatment mobilizes available supports (family, therapist, psychiatrist, family doctor, and/or mutual support organizations) rather than creating temporary and artificial supports that will be removed once a residential experience ends.
  • Indigenous recovery supports are identified and activated during the course of outpatient treatment.
  • The transition from active outpatient treatment into social support and recovery maintenance is much less abrupt than with residential treatment. Social support gains are generalized into real life.
  • Clinical changes, recovery supportive resources, therapeutic and professional relationships are likely to be maintained.

 

Addiction creates casualties and long-lasting problems. How is this wreckage handled differently in an outpatient setting treating substance use disorders?

  • People coming to terms with an addiction often face mounting financial, vocational and domestic problems- “wreckage”.
  • Treatment should not add to those mounting bills, unnecessary absence from work and home.
  • Rehab should instead help move you into the solution- toward resolving the “wreckage” of your addiction.

 

Why is residential treatment so widely recognized as the way to get sober?

  • Residential treatment will produce better profit/ development margins for the business owner/ provider of care if critical business volumes can be achieved.
  • The higher operating costs, administrative time, and professional oversight of residential components draw decision-makers to focus on their residential treatment at the expense of their less complex and less lucrative outpatient services.
  • It is clear to the margin-oriented administrator that short-term financial gains will be best made from a residential model if only the beds can be filled.

 

Substance Use Disorder or Addiction

The words we use to describe alcoholism and drug addiction evolve with social, political and scientific change. Alcoholism and drug addiction have been the subject of huge social scorn and condemnation. People who cannot control their alcohol consumption and others who use other addictive drugs bring tragedy upon not only themselves, but also to their loved ones and society as a whole.

Eighty years ago as people began to recover for the first time, their stories became better understood. Medicine began to advocate for greater research as the biological causes of this “disease” were discovered. Prejudice, judgement and shame slowly subsided as solutions began to be uncovered; hope replaced disgrace.

Terms change as greater information is uncovered. Professionals from medicine, psychology, sociology, criminology, theology, etc. bring unique perspectives to the far reaching impacts of alcohol and drug abuse. The words we now describe “Substance Use Disorder” attempts to diminish stigma while capturing the essential characteristics of the disorder which includes a continuum of intensity and severity.

What was once a hopeless condition viewed as sinful, weak, criminal, deviant, crazy is now viewed as a chronic, relapsing medical disease which has far reaching impact. Alcoholism and drug addiction became chemical abuse or dependent. Substance abuse and dependency is now considered substance abuse disorder. This new concept describes a continuum of symptoms from mild to severe, allowing each individual unique characteristics and consequences.

In-Network HMO, EPO and PPO Covered Addiction Rehab

Working people and their families are often covered by affordable health care coverage offered through managed healthcare plans such as HMO’s (heath management organizations), EPO’s (exclusive provider organizations) and PPO’s (preferred provider organizations). The Affordable Care Act has resulted in healthcare exchanges such as “Covered California” where people can purchase affordable healthcare insurance which is priced according to their income.

HMO, EPO, and PPO insurance plans usually relegate behavioral healthcare coverage and management to behavioral healthcare departments or organizations. The reason that services provided by alcohol and drug rehabilitation and treatment centers are managed separately by behavioral health departments is that diagnoses, prognoses and progress cannot be measured through conventional biological markers or measurement tools. A specialist in behavioral health is required to determine the level and type of care needed for complex diseases such as alcoholism and drug addiction now referred to as “substance use disorders”.

Costs and personal restrictions are better contained when a professional who is financially independent from the provider oversees care and monitors costs. Treatment can become exorbitantly expensive when there exists no such oversight. For some people with wealth, rehab can be combined with an extended luxury vacation. Not everyone can or should afford luxury or lengthy treatment.

When you seek a provider contracted with your insurance healthcare plan, the coverage is much better and the services are closely monitored for quality and cost. Ethical business practices can also be enforced such as providing you and your family about the best estimate of cost before a contract is signed.

Providers who are “out-of-network” will often state that they accept insurance. Before signing contracts, take the following steps to protect yourself:

  • Ask the out of network provider if they will give you a written estimate of what the out-of-pocket cost will be after the insurance stops authorizing payment for treatment
  • Ask if they will provide you an itemized bill which they send to your insurance company, including the charges for urinalysis
  • Ask if the provider gets approved for all services rendered and ask how long the insurance company is likely to approve payment
  • Ask if they bill you the balance after the insurance company ceases to cover treatment and how much that total is likely to run.

To protect you and your family from unethical business practices or to avoid unnecessary costs and services, ask you insurance representative or therapist for their expert opinion.